I Won An Argument. Really?
I was thinking about arguments the other day. Not the big ones that make the news. The ordinary ones. The ones that happen between two people who actually care about each other. A husband and wife arguing about something neither of them will remember six months from now. Two friends disagreeing over who was right. A parent and an adult child having the same conversation they've had three times before. And I realized something rather odd. When we get into an argument, we often behave as though there are only two possible outcomes. One person wins. The other loses. And, naturally, we would prefer to be the one holding the trophy. We gather evidence. We remember things the other person said three years ago. We prepare the perfect comeback while pretending to listen. And sometimes, just to make absolutely certain our victory is complete, we raise our voice. But here's the strange part. You can win the argument and still lose something far more valuable. The conversation. The closeness. The ease between two people. Perhaps even the relationship itself. So maybe there is another way to think about winning. Make the argument better, not louder. When a disagreement gets heated, volume rarely adds much intelligence to the room. A better question might be: Can I make my argument clearer? Can I understand what the other person is actually trying to say? Can I find the one part of their argument that might be true? Can I disagree without making the other person feel small? You don't make your thinking stronger by making everyone else quieter. You make it stronger by allowing good arguments into the room. And perhaps our relationships work the same way. The goal of a disagreement doesn't always have to be: "How do I prove that I'm right?" Sometimes it can be: "How do we get closer to what is right?" That small change can transform an argument. Because now the other person isn't the opponent. They're part of the search. And perhaps there is an even more interesting kind of victory. You make your point. They make theirs. Neither of you completely changes your mind. But you both understand each other a little better than you did before. Nobody gets a trophy. Nobody storms away. And somehow, both people leave richer. Maybe that's a win worth having. So the next time you find yourself in an argument with someone who matters to you, perhaps notice what you are actually trying to win. The argument? Or the person? So, I want your take on this: If being right meant losing someone you love, would you still call it winning? Until tomorrow. Bob.
Join the conversation